Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 2,094 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 1,329,982
Pageviews Today: 2,205,251Threads Today: 843Posts Today: 15,046
09:34 PM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

The Shadow Aspect

 
Kaosofik
Offer Upgrade

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 02:55 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
The Shadow Aspect




"Everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves."
Carl Gustav Jung
"There is no coming to consciousness without pain."
Carl Gustav Jung

The shadow or "shadow aspect" is a part of the unconscious mind which is mysterious and often disagreeable to the conscious mind, but which is also relatively close to the conscious mind. It may be (in part) one's link to animal life, which is superseded during early childhood by the conscious mind; afterwards it comes to contain thoughts that are repressed by the conscious mind. According to Jung, the shadow is instinctive and irrational, but is not necessarily evil even when it might appear to be so. It can be both ruthless in conflict and empathetic in friendship. It is important as a source of hunches, for understanding of one's own more inexplicable actions and attitudes (and of others' reactions), and for learning how to accept and integrate the more problematic or troubling aspects of one's personality. (from the wiki).


The shadow is the most clearly recognizable of the characteristic archetypes. Becoming conscious of your shadow means accepting that the dark aspects of your own personality really exist. This acceptance forms the basis of all self-knowledge, and usually finds a lot of resistance. The shadow is a moral problem that challenges the whole ego-personality, for no one can become conscious of the shadow without considerable moral effort. Through a thorough investigation of the dark character aspects and inadequacies respectively, that form the shadow together, seems that these posess a an emotional nature or a certain autonomy. That's why they have an obsessing influence, and we can even become posessed by it. Emotion is namely not an action we perform, but an occasion that happens to us. Affects or emotion usually show up on those matters we are least adjusted to. At the same time they reveal the reason of the lesser adjustment, namely a inadequacy and a lower level of the personality at that specific point. On this deeper level with it's barely or not at all controlled emotions we behave more or less as a primitive human. We are then not only a victim of our emotions without any will of our own, but also remarkably little capable of a moral judgement.
While now the shadow with the help of insight and good will can be fitted somewhat into the conscious personality, there are also, as experience learns us, certain traits that stubbornly resist any moral control, and seem as good as uninfluencable. In the rule these resistances are weaved in with projections, that are not recognized as such. Insight in the own projections means a moral achievement that surpasses the common average. While the characterisstics ofthe shadow can be recognized without too much trouble as properties belonging to one's own personality, insight aswell as will are lacking with the confrontation of the projections. The origin of the emotions that guide the projection seem without a doubt to rest with the other (on whom one projets).
The projecting is namely as known not the conscious human, but the unconscious. A projection is encountered - not made by ourselves. The effect of projections is the isolation of the human his environment, seeing as he does not have a real realtionship with it, but only an illusionary. Projections change the environment in its own, but unknown insight. They lead because of this in last instance to an auto-erotic or autistic situation, wherein one dreams a world - the reality of the world however remains unreachable. The feeling of incompleteness and the even worse feeling of sterility that are the effect of this, are in their turn again explained through projection as evilwillingness of the environment, and thanks to this vicious cycle the isolation increases. The more projections are shoved between the subject and his environment, the harder it becomes for the I to see through his illusions. It is often tragic to see how a man, often in a very transparent manner, ruins his own life and that of others, while he can't see for all the money of hte world that the entire mess came from the greatest part out of himself, and again and again is fed and maintained by him. That is by the way not the not the work of his consciousness, cause that complains and curses about a unfaithfull world, that keeps retreating itself. The guilty is on the contrary an unconsicous factor, that spins world and self-hiding illusions. This fantasy world is indeed a cocoon that causes the concerning human to be totally encapsulated.
The shadow can be seen through and realized with a little self-criticism easily - for as so far it is of a personal nature at least. In other words: It is in our capabilities to know the relative-evil of our nature.
Adapted from Carl Gustav Jung: "I and Self: The I - The self. Christ, a symbol of the self."

"Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate."
Carl Gustav Jung
"People will do anything, no matter how absurd to stop from facing their souls."
Carl Gustav Jung

"The foundation of all mental illness is the unwillingness to experience legitimate suffering."
Carl Gustav Jung

[link to www.dedroidify.com]
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:03 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:07 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Are you in the Shadow of your Daykeeper?



Have you unconsciously created a reality in which you seem lost or confused? In this shadow, you may feel enmeshed in the illusions of the hall of mirrors. Remember that the only real power the hall of mirrors has is your belief that its grand illusions are real! On Earth, we presently live on a holographic playing field made of the elements of time and space. This field draws to itself the density and mass necessary to form a three-dimensional reality. All phenomena within it are images that appear for our learning and growth. Since each of us is a hologram of light within the larger hologram, getting lost in fear, judgement, and denial can certainly appear to be "real", but it is really only an illusion. The essential mind is silent, still, empty - hence, incapable of getting lost.

The transformation offered in this shadow is found by being mindful. Meditate and pray for the reestablishment of your direct connection to Spirit. Become quiet and still. Imagine yourself floating timelessly in the center of the star-glyph White Mirror, receiving divine wisdom. Cut away with clear discrimination. Forgive and release yourself and others. Enter into the timeless truth of the spiritual warrior.

Another shadow transformation of White Mirror may be found in seeing yourself clearly in the mirrors of the world and other people. Using others as mirrors allows you to experience hidden truths about yourself. Ask for honest feedback from friends you trust. Risk hearing the truth about yourself. Openly observe the events in your life to see how they can be used to better understand who you actually are.

One of the most self-limiting illusions is the belief that one's own view of reality is the only one. This often causes the mirror of the world to reflect back to you your "unseen" shadow, and when you see this shadow, it can produce a judgement or reaction. Such emotionally charged situations usually have two poles or positions. When you believe that only you are right, both poles remain charged and fixed. For a moment, experiment with letting go or changing your position. As you loosen your hold and step aside, the "other position" or person is freed to change as well.

Understand that judgement and acceptance are two sides of the same mirror - the transparent mirror of ascension.

[link to www.astrodreamadvisor.com]
Tat Tvam Asi
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:09 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.
 Quoting: Indy2517

Maybe we put them there?
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:32 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?
 Quoting: Kaosofik


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:44 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?
 Quoting: Indy2517

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.
Tat Tvam Asi
ObeWayneKenobe

User ID: 935963
United States
04/23/2010 03:46 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?
 Quoting: Kaosofik

Or maybe we allow them in......?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 944524
United States
04/23/2010 03:48 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Hello Kaos, Indy.
A good read.
Lots to ponder in this one.

I'll get further into it later this eve.

Peace to the both of you.

hf
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:52 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.
 Quoting: Kaosofik


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:53 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?

Or maybe we allow them in......?
 Quoting: ObeWayneKenobe

I think that if anything they are put there. Conditioning since birth.
Although I do agree with you to certain extent. It's up to us what we do with it later on.

Last Edited by Kaosofik Gnostik on 04/23/2010 03:57 PM
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:54 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Hello Kaos, Indy.
A good read.
Lots to ponder in this one.

I'll get further into it later this eve.

Peace to the both of you.

hf
 Quoting: BatBoy


Hey BB,

yeah it IS a good subject, lots of room for discussion. Good call Kaos.
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 03:56 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?
 Quoting: Indy2517

With Nicolas Cage right? Yeah, it's been a while though.

I'll have to think about us being born with a moral compass.
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:06 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?

With Nicolas Cage right? Yeah, it's been a while though.

I'll have to think about us being born with a moral compass.
 Quoting: Kaosofik


Well I mentioned it, because the killer tells Cage he had a normal childhood , etc. So that begs the question, what's wrong with him? I'll see if I can find a real world comparison.
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:07 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?
 Quoting: Indy2517

Okay...I think I get what you mean by moral compass. So again I think it is up to us to decide what we do with it. Do we dare think/step outside the box and deal with things other than what was given to us? (normal childhood etc.)

In modern moral psychology, morality is considered to CHANGE THROUGH PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT. A number of psychologists have produced theories on the development of morals, usually going through stages of different morals. Lawrence Kohlberg, Jean Piaget, and Elliot Turiel have cognitive-developmental approaches to moral development; to these theorists morality forms in a series of constructive stages or domains. Social psychologists such as Martin Hoffman and Jonathan Haidt emphasize social and emotional development based on biology, such as empathy. Moral identity theorists, such as William Damon and Mordechai Nisan, see moral commitment as arising from the development of a self-identity that is defined by moral purposes: this moral self-identity leads to a sense of responsibility to pursue such purposes...

Last Edited by Kaosofik Gnostik on 04/23/2010 04:10 PM
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 943894
United States
04/23/2010 04:13 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
That video is awesome...

But no offense, Jung was a retard.

He complicated what is simple and relatively easy to understand. By labeling all these "sides" of people he makes it appear as if there are different people inside us...it's not like that...

Exploring who you are is not getting to know different parts of yourself...it's getting to know one simple truth inside each of us...that we all share.

I don't know...it can be perceived so many ways...it's good to hear others views on that.

hf
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 943894
United States
04/23/2010 04:14 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Do we dare think/step outside the box and deal with things other than what was given to us? (normal childhood etc.)
 Quoting: Kaosofik


See that there is no box...maybe...
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:16 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Do we dare think/step outside the box and deal with things other than what was given to us? (normal childhood etc.)


See that there is no box...maybe...
 Quoting: ArunaLuna

lmao


There is no spoon.


wink
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:22 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?

Okay...I think I get what you mean by moral compass. So again I think it is up to us to decide what we do with it. Do we dare think/step outside the box and deal with things other than what was given to us? (normal childhood etc.)

In modern moral psychology, morality is considered to CHANGE THROUGH PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT. A number of psychologists have produced theories on the development of morals, usually going through stages of different morals. Lawrence Kohlberg, Jean Piaget, and Elliot Turiel have cognitive-developmental approaches to moral development; to these theorists morality forms in a series of constructive stages or domains. Social psychologists such as Martin Hoffman and Jonathan Haidt emphasize social and emotional development based on biology, such as empathy. Moral identity theorists, such as William Damon and Mordechai Nisan, see moral commitment as arising from the development of a self-identity that is defined by moral purposes: this moral self-identity leads to a sense of responsibility to pursue such purposes...
 Quoting: Kaosofik


That's just my point, do we all have the same base from which we start building our identity? Why is it that some people that are abused turn into abusers, while some do not? Is it all a result of external influences or are some people just born differently. What about our innate beliefs? Are these factors taken into account?
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:23 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
That video is awesome...

But no offense, Jung was a retard.

He complicated what is simple and relatively easy to understand. By labeling all these "sides" of people he makes it appear as if there are different people inside us...it's not like that...

Exploring who you are is not getting to know different parts of yourself...it's getting to know one simple truth inside each of us...that we all share.

I don't know...it can be perceived so many ways...it's good to hear others views on that.

hf
 Quoting: ArunaLuna


I don't see it as different people inside of us...it's all part of us.
How else are we to experience the "simple truth" if we do not experience the "lies"?
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:28 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
That video is awesome...

But no offense, Jung was a retard.

He complicated what is simple and relatively easy to understand. By labeling all these "sides" of people he makes it appear as if there are different people inside us...it's not like that...

Exploring who you are is not getting to know different parts of yourself...it's getting to know one simple truth inside each of us...that we all share.

I don't know...it can be perceived so many ways...it's good to hear others views on that.

hf
 Quoting: ArunaLuna


Well that's the prerogative of science, complicating matters... Especially in fields such as Psychology, which for the most part is purely theoretical. It's based on statistics mostly. I keep it in high regard though.
AWhereness

User ID: 908143
United States
04/23/2010 04:33 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?
 Quoting: Indy2517

Our minds are so much bigger than we are! With this incredible capacity, it feeds on what we are consciously giving it as well as that which we just view in passing. Like being absorbed on the periphery of our awareness. And it does confront us; that is what Jung meant by that first line. We are not always conscious of what has made us to this point. That storehouse is available to us when we are able to still the chatter up front and center. We can finally get to the immense library of archives and possibilities that are our Being.
When we remember we are all mad, the mysteries disappear and life stands explained.

Mark Twain
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:33 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
Well I agree we should face our inner demons and be aware of our less-than-admirable qualities. However one must ask oneself WHY these traits reside in our subconcious.

Maybe we put them there?


Yeah probably, but why? Why can't we be confronted with that side of us?

I think we have been conditioned since birth on what is "right" and what is "wrong". We are told that darkness is evil/wrong. Yet we are in our mother's womb for 9 months in total darkness. Were we afraid of darkness then? I think not.
It has been a distraction to keep us from knowing that it is all one. At the same time I think it is something we must experience in order for us to understand.


You have a good point there, although sometimes I wonder if our sense of right and wrong is just conditioning. I believe we're born with a rudimental moral compass. This reminds me of the movie 8mm, did you see it?

Okay...I think I get what you mean by moral compass. So again I think it is up to us to decide what we do with it. Do we dare think/step outside the box and deal with things other than what was given to us? (normal childhood etc.)

In modern moral psychology, morality is considered to CHANGE THROUGH PERSONAL DEVELOPMENT. A number of psychologists have produced theories on the development of morals, usually going through stages of different morals. Lawrence Kohlberg, Jean Piaget, and Elliot Turiel have cognitive-developmental approaches to moral development; to these theorists morality forms in a series of constructive stages or domains. Social psychologists such as Martin Hoffman and Jonathan Haidt emphasize social and emotional development based on biology, such as empathy. Moral identity theorists, such as William Damon and Mordechai Nisan, see moral commitment as arising from the development of a self-identity that is defined by moral purposes: this moral self-identity leads to a sense of responsibility to pursue such purposes...


That's just my point, do we all have the same base from which we start building our identity? Why is it that some people that are abused turn into abusers, while some do not? Is it all a result of external influences or are some people just born differently. What about our inane beliefs? Are these factors taken into account?
 Quoting: Indy2517

hmm

I think "external" influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is "internal" (will). If someone is willing to expand their awareness or not.

Last Edited by Kaosofik Gnostik on 04/23/2010 04:40 PM
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:47 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hmm

I think external influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is internal (will).
 Quoting: Kaosofik


True, willpower does play a role in it, but what I was aiming at was defects. Basically what we're talking about here is the nature of evil, I've already stated several times I'm not religious, but I'm starting to believe more and more that some people are just born incomplete. Could be a defect in their brain, could be something more elusive. To sum it up, I think we're all the products of BOTH our environment AND our innate properties.

The thing is, if you're born in a way society deems evil, how do you deal with such persons should they commit crimes? Story of the turtle and the scorpion comes to mind.

A turtle was happily swimming along a river when a scorpion hailed it from the shore.

"Dear friend turtle!" called the scorpion. "Please let me climb upon your back and swim me to the other side of the river!"

"No," replied the turtle, "for if I do, you shall sting me, and I shall die."

"Nonsense!" replied the scorpion. "If I kill you in the middle of the river, you shall sink, and I shall drown and die with you."

The turtle thought this over, and saw the truth of the scorpion's statement. He let it upon his back and began swimming towards the other side of the river. Halfway across, he felt a sharp pain in the back of his neck.

"Why have you stung me?!" cried the turtle as his body began to stiffen. "Now you shall die as well!"

"Because it is in my nature," replied the scorpion as the turtle sank beneath the waters.
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 04:58 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hmm

I think external influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is internal (will).


True, willpower does play a role in it, but what I was aiming at was defects. Basically what we're talking about here is the nature of evil, I've already stated several times I'm not religious, but I'm starting to believe more and more that some people are just born incomplete. Could be a defect in their brain, could be something more elusive. To sum it up, I think we're all the products of BOTH our environment AND our inate properties.

The thing is, if you're born in a way society deems evil, how do you deal with such persons should they commit crimes?
 Quoting: Indy2517

Are these defects natural or caused by man? Either way they are here for a reason/purpose.

Last Edited by Kaosofik Gnostik on 04/23/2010 04:58 PM
Tat Tvam Asi
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 05:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hmm

I think external influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is internal (will).


True, willpower does play a role in it, but what I was aiming at was defects. Basically what we're talking about here is the nature of evil, I've already stated several times I'm not religious, but I'm starting to believe more and more that some people are just born incomplete. Could be a defect in their brain, could be something more elusive. To sum it up, I think we're all the products of BOTH our environment AND our inate properties.

The thing is, if you're born in a way society deems evil, how do you deal with such persons should they commit crimes?

Are these defects natural or caused by man? Either way they are here for a reason/purpose.
 Quoting: Kaosofik


Hmm that's hard to answer. Let's assume, they're natural(or indirectly caused by man through pollution or something). Sometimes when you use a xerox machine you get a bad copy. I'm not sure what their purpose is though, seems to me they got the short end of the stick. They do horrible things, in part because their nature compels them and we punish them for it ( no other solution). Only reason for their existence might be so we can learn from them and maybe avoid a repeat of these events.
Kaosofik  (OP)

User ID: 759722
Netherlands
04/23/2010 05:24 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hmm

I think external influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is internal (will).


True, willpower does play a role in it, but what I was aiming at was defects. Basically what we're talking about here is the nature of evil, I've already stated several times I'm not religious, but I'm starting to believe more and more that some people are just born incomplete. Could be a defect in their brain, could be something more elusive. To sum it up, I think we're all the products of BOTH our environment AND our inate properties.

The thing is, if you're born in a way society deems evil, how do you deal with such persons should they commit crimes?

Are these defects natural or caused by man? Either way they are here for a reason/purpose.


Hmm that's hard to answer. Let's assume, they're natural(or indirectly caused by man through pollution or something). Sometimes when you use a xerox machine you get a bad copy. I'm not sure what their purpose is though, seems to me they got the short end of the stick. They do horrible things, in part because their nature compels them and we punish them for it ( no other solution). Only reason for their existence might be so we can learn from them and maybe avoid a repeat of these events.
 Quoting: Indy2517

But are we learning from them by punishing them?
Maybe that just causes even worse defects in the future.
And maybe they are not defects. After all, they are a part of us. Is that our way of not dealing with our shadows?

Last Edited by Kaosofik Gnostik on 04/23/2010 05:26 PM
Tat Tvam Asi
nanuke

User ID: 815174
United States
04/23/2010 05:28 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hugs
~you are love
~the key...it's almost time.

!poke the bulge!

~here is my hand...it can be closed like a fist...or open to hold...yet it is still my hand.
~Today is cancelled...due to lack of interest.
~Without order nothing exists. Without chaos nothing evolves.

ac 618285:
~"without both order and chaos, the illusion would not be able to continue.
one day in the far away future, order will submit to chaos and the entire illusion will vanish."
--------------------------------
:nan1:
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 916957
Netherlands
04/23/2010 05:50 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
hmm

I think external influences do play a role. But I also believe a lot of it is internal (will).


True, willpower does play a role in it, but what I was aiming at was defects. Basically what we're talking about here is the nature of evil, I've already stated several times I'm not religious, but I'm starting to believe more and more that some people are just born incomplete. Could be a defect in their brain, could be something more elusive. To sum it up, I think we're all the products of BOTH our environment AND our inate properties.

The thing is, if you're born in a way society deems evil, how do you deal with such persons should they commit crimes?

Are these defects natural or caused by man? Either way they are here for a reason/purpose.


Hmm that's hard to answer. Let's assume, they're natural(or indirectly caused by man through pollution or something). Sometimes when you use a xerox machine you get a bad copy. I'm not sure what their purpose is though, seems to me they got the short end of the stick. They do horrible things, in part because their nature compels them and we punish them for it ( no other solution). Only reason for their existence might be so we can learn from them and maybe avoid a repeat of these events.

But are we learning from them by punishing them?
Maybe that just causes even worse defects in the future.
And maybe they are not defects. After all, they are a part of us. Is that our way of not dealing with our shadows?
 Quoting: Kaosofik


Well punish might not be the right word. Punishment implies rehabilitation. But some people cannot be returned to society, can not be rehabilitated, because of the risk they pose. Such people should be "studied", it sounds clinical, but I believe in doing so we're helping them and ourselves. But I get the feeling I'm starting to veer away from the main point here. When we're talking about relatively sane persons, I agree they should get the chance to redeem themselves.
Kevin
User ID: 1196653
Netherlands
12/15/2010 08:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
live!



most people are stupid, not uncouincesses, no good souls

Think that they talk stupid, ónly think

Believe yourself.


I like what i do, i do what i like

14-08-1990'

5a
kevin again
User ID: 1196653
Netherlands
12/15/2010 08:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: The Shadow Aspect
people can choose, choose people





GLP