Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 1,707 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 64,377
Pageviews Today: 118,793Threads Today: 60Posts Today: 844
01:08 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.

 
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1090909
Canada
09/06/2010 04:34 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Do you believe in Jesus?

To me jesus was a good qumranian essene jew who tried to lead a people back to abrahamic tradition and preached love faith and hope. I believe he was a prophet and a good man.

I just fail to see those qualities in fervent Muslims.

May you find truth.


look, edmund, you can't mix and match spitual truths.

pick one and stick to it or you'll trip all over yourself.

from now on you will be Mohammed Dantes to me.
------------------
as you wish. BTW I am not mix and match spiritual truths...I am explaining what I understand to be a singular absolute truth.
 Quoting: Edmond Dantes

Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another. There is a bit of truth to be found in all of them. Some are less confusing than others and some suffer more or less cultural overlay that inhibits the view of the spiritual message. No one person has a mind large enough for a "singular absolute truth" and so must select those aspects that suit them personally.
Edmond Dantes  (OP)

User ID: 1032741
Canada
09/06/2010 04:34 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
as to the poster concerning the Eucharist. Transubstantiation (the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of christ) following the rubrics laid out in the Ordo is a rendition of the melchizadekean way.

We have a difference of opinion ....you believe it to turn into jesus because of the Mass....I believe its bread and wine.


The Holy Eucharist is true, believe, and why would you wish it otherwise? Since 33 A.D. at the Last Supper, Christ gave to us Himself, body, blood, soul and divinity. You have no spiritual life in you if you deny the Eucharist as Jesus states in John 6:54. Very soon, God in His mercy is going to try to convince the entire world this time.

Then Jesus said to them: Amen, amen I say unto you: Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.


Where is the divine in Islam? Give one witness to the unexplained, to the miraculous. I asked for the simple good to show God's presence in Islam previous, unless I missed it, no reply. Speak of the miraculous, you can't come up with it either.

Watch the video, miracles within miracles.


[youtube] [link to www.youtube.com]
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929

I did not answer because it tends to e a baited question not because I do not have examples. What would satisfy you? David Hume's cri de cour. well how about the very existance of Islam. There is more justification for Abrahams' (PBUH) religion to have died out than to exist still. Not all miracles are the parting of the sea...
1:1.618 ratio
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 05:43 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
look, edmund, you can't mix and match spitual truths.

pick one and stick to it or you'll trip all over yourself.

from now on you will be Mohammed Dantes to me.
------------------
as you wish. BTW I am not mix and match spiritual truths...I am explaining what I understand to be a singular absolute truth.

===========

Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another. There is a bit of truth to be found in all of them. Some are less confusing than others and some suffer more or less cultural overlay that inhibits the view of the spiritual message. No one person has a mind large enough for a "singular absolute truth" and so must select those aspects that suit them personally.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1090909


Yes, there is too a "singular absolute truth."

The Ac, God bless him or her though, is saying we cannot know God's plan or the reason we are here. That would make God evil. He is not, He is all love. He has revealed His love and plan for mankind.

True but very sad, there are a lot of religions, Christian and non-Christian but there is only one faith. Like the
Bible says. "One Lord, one faith, one baptism"

It's interesting...the OP's words..."There is a bit of truth to be found in all of them."

God the Father said the same in a message from Heaven, He
was talking about the Religions of the world. Then He
continued...with...only in the Roman Catholic Church can the fullness of Truth be found. Makes sense, Jesus established His Church in 33 A.D., we know...read Matthew 16:18.

I can post the message from God the Father.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 05:49 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
as to the poster concerning the Eucharist. Transubstantiation (the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of christ) following the rubrics laid out in the Ordo is a rendition of the melchizadekean way.

We have a difference of opinion ....you believe it to turn into jesus because of the Mass....I believe its bread and wine.


The Holy Eucharist is true, believe, and why would you wish it otherwise? Since 33 A.D. at the Last Supper, Christ gave to us Himself, body, blood, soul and divinity. You have no spiritual life in you if you deny the Eucharist as Jesus states in John 6:54. Very soon, God in His mercy is going to try to convince the entire world this time.

Then Jesus said to them: Amen, amen I say unto you: Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.


Where is the divine in Islam? Give one witness to the unexplained, to the miraculous. I asked for the simple good to show God's presence in Islam previous, unless I missed it, no reply. Speak of the miraculous, you can't come up with it either.

Watch the video, miracles within miracles.


[youtube] [link to www.youtube.com]

I did not answer because it tends to e a baited question not because I do not have examples.
What would satisfy you? David Hume's cri de cour. well how about the very existance of Islam. There is more justification for Abrahams' (PBUH) religion to have died out than to exist still. Not all miracles are the parting of the sea...
 Quoting: Edmond Dantes


Excuse!

You can't name the Roman Catholic Seminary or the director and there is no "good" or "miracles" to show the fruit, the presence of God in Islam.

You can't give one instance.

Jesus is present in the Holy Eucharist and you have walked
away...if you really ever were Roman Catholic.

And for what...alone, we see how Islam treats defenseless
women. Like dirt.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1091342
United States
09/06/2010 06:00 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1090909


here you betray your self confessed muslim religion, my dear

jazakAllah Dantes!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1091342
United States
09/06/2010 06:10 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another[/b].


here you betray your self confessed muslim religion, my dear

jazakAllah Dantes!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1091342


i warned you of this, my dear jazakAllah.

that you chose to ignore is your cross to bear.

a house divided is seminary 1011

adiou me amigo.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 956677
United States
09/06/2010 06:12 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
So you now condone Sharia Law and the stoning of young girls and ten year olds being forced to marry old men, honor killings and all that is Islam?

This makes the world a better place? I don't see how it does.
 Quoting: Bluebird



It is obvious you have never read the Old Testament or the Talmud. (Talmud filth will get removed from here) Your examples are mild. Is there some reason you don't read your bible?

If a man have a stubborn and rebellious son, which will not obey the voice of his father, or the voice of his mother, and that, when they have chastened him, will not hearken unto them: Then shall his father and his mother lay hold on him, and bring him out unto the elders of his city, and unto the gate of his place; And they shall say unto the elders of his city, This our son is stubborn and rebellious, he will not obey our voice; he is a glutton, and a drunkard. And all the men of his city shall stone him with stones, that he die: so shalt thou put evil away from among you; and all Israel shall hear, and fear. -- Deuteronomy 21:18-21

He that smiteth his father, or his mother, shall be surely put to death. -- Exodus 21:15

He that curseth his father, or his mother, shall surely be put to death. -- Exodus 21:17

Children who mock their parents will have their eyes plucked out by ravens and eaten by eagles.

The eye that mocketh at his father, and despiseth to obey his mother, the ravens of the valley shall pick it out, and the young eagles shall eat it. -- Proverbs 30:17

The eye that mocketh at his father, and despiseth to obey his mother, the ravens of the valley shall pick it out, and the young eagles shall eat it. -- Proverbs 30:17


[link to skepticsannotatedbible.com]
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 956677
United States
09/06/2010 06:20 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
as to the poster concerning the Eucharist. Transubstantiation (the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of christ) following the rubrics laid out in the Ordo is a rendition of the melchizadekean way.

We have a difference of opinion ....you believe it to turn into jesus because of the Mass....I believe its bread and wine.


The Holy Eucharist is true, believe, and why would you wish it otherwise? Since 33 A.D. at the Last Supper, Christ gave to us Himself, body, blood, soul and divinity. You have no spiritual life in you if you deny the Eucharist as Jesus states in John 6:54. Very soon, God in His mercy is going to try to convince the entire world this time.

Then Jesus said to them: Amen, amen I say unto you: Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.


Where is the divine in Islam? Give one witness to the unexplained, to the miraculous. I asked for the simple good to show God's presence in Islam previous, unless I missed it, no reply. Speak of the miraculous, you can't come up with it either.

Watch the video, miracles within miracles.


[youtube] [link to www.youtube.com]

I did not answer because it tends to e a baited question not because I do not have examples.
What would satisfy you? David Hume's cri de cour. well how about the very existance of Islam. There is more justification for Abrahams' (PBUH) religion to have died out than to exist still. Not all miracles are the parting of the sea...


Excuse!

You can't name the Roman Catholic Seminary or the director and there is no "good" or "miracles" to show the fruit, the presence of God in Islam.

You can't give one instance.

Jesus is present in the Holy Eucharist and you have walked
away...if you really ever were Roman Catholic.

And for what...alone, we see how Islam treats defenseless
women. Like dirt.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929



Magical beliefs (miracles)...wasn't that the reason for the "pagan" genocides?

The Roman Catholics, aka Inquisition and inspiration of millenia of war, rape and pillage and witch burnings...defenseless women...at the stake...sorry, you don't get a free pass to absolution.

It's all insanity.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 725839
United States
09/06/2010 06:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
as to the poster concerning the Eucharist. Transubstantiation (the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of christ) following the rubrics laid out in the Ordo is a rendition of the melchizadekean way.

We have a difference of opinion ....you believe it to turn into jesus because of the Mass....I believe its bread and wine.


The Holy Eucharist is true, believe, and why would you wish it otherwise? Since 33 A.D. at the Last Supper, Christ gave to us Himself, body, blood, soul and divinity. You have no spiritual life in you if you deny the Eucharist as Jesus states in John 6:54. Very soon, God in His mercy is going to try to convince the entire world this time.

Then Jesus said to them: Amen, amen I say unto you: Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.


Where is the divine in Islam? Give one witness to the unexplained, to the miraculous. I asked for the simple good to show God's presence in Islam previous, unless I missed it, no reply. Speak of the miraculous, you can't come up with it either.

Watch the video, miracles within miracles.


[youtube] [link to www.youtube.com]

I did not answer because it tends to e a baited question not because I do not have examples.
What would satisfy you? David Hume's cri de cour. well how about the very existance of Islam. There is more justification for Abrahams' (PBUH) religion to have died out than to exist still. Not all miracles are the parting of the sea...


Excuse!

You can't name the Roman Catholic Seminary or the director and there is no "good" or "miracles" to show the fruit, the presence of God in Islam.

You can't give one instance.

Jesus is present in the Holy Eucharist and you have walked
away...if you really ever were Roman Catholic.

And for what...alone, we see how Islam treats defenseless
women. Like dirt.



Magical beliefs (miracles)...wasn't that the reason for the "pagan" genocides?

The Roman Catholics, aka Inquisition and inspiration of millenia of war, rape and pillage and witch burnings...defenseless women...at the stake...sorry, you don't get a free pass to absolution.

It's all insanity.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 956677


Game, Set and Match.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1091342
United States
09/06/2010 06:28 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another[/b].


here you betray your self confessed muslim religion, my dear

jazakAllah Dantes!


i warned you of this, my dear jazakAllah.

that you chose to ignore is your cross to bear.

a house divided is seminary 1011

adiou me amigo.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1091342


"...that he would be torn apart by the jackals of unleavened..."

someone may have said that sometime, once.

bon apetite my good amigos, adeiu.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 07:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
as to the poster concerning the Eucharist. Transubstantiation (the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of christ) following the rubrics laid out in the Ordo is a rendition of the melchizadekean way.

We have a difference of opinion ....you believe it to turn into jesus because of the Mass....I believe its bread and wine.


The Holy Eucharist is true, believe, and why would you wish it otherwise? Since 33 A.D. at the Last Supper, Christ gave to us Himself, body, blood, soul and divinity. You have no spiritual life in you if you deny the Eucharist as Jesus states in John 6:54. Very soon, God in His mercy is going to try to convince the entire world this time.

Then Jesus said to them: Amen, amen I say unto you: Except you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you.


Where is the divine in Islam? Give one witness to the unexplained, to the miraculous. I asked for the simple good to show God's presence in Islam previous, unless I missed it, no reply. Speak of the miraculous, you can't come up with it either.

Watch the video, miracles within miracles.


[youtube] [link to www.youtube.com]

I did not answer because it tends to e a baited question not because I do not have examples.
What would satisfy you? David Hume's cri de cour. well how about the very existance of Islam. There is more justification for Abrahams' (PBUH) religion to have died out than to exist still. Not all miracles are the parting of the sea...


Excuse!

You can't name the Roman Catholic Seminary or the director and there is no "good" or "miracles" to show the fruit, the presence of God in Islam.

You can't give one instance.

Jesus is present in the Holy Eucharist and you have walked
away...if you really ever were Roman Catholic.

And for what...alone, we see how Islam treats defenseless
women. Like dirt.



Magical beliefs (miracles)...wasn't that the reason for the "pagan" genocides?

The Roman Catholics, aka Inquisition and inspiration of millenia of war, rape and pillage and witch burnings...defenseless women...at the stake...sorry, you don't get a free pass to absolution.

It's all insanity.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 956677


Reply to the Protestant English Inquisition and persecution and we see until this day of Catholics!!

Thomas More was martyred because he would not bow down to
the lies of Protestant heresy.

And there is a beautiful country enslaved right now because of Protestantism. Did you forget Ireland.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 725839
United States
09/06/2010 07:36 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Reply to the Protestant English Inquisition and persecution and we see until this day of Catholics!!

Thomas More was martyred because he would not bow down to
the lies of Protestant heresy.

And there is a beautiful country enslaved right now because of Protestantism. Did you forget Ireland.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929


Pardon me Peewee, but have you ever noticed that "religion" in general and the abegod blood cults in particular are all about slavery?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1091464
United States
09/06/2010 07:40 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another[/b].


here you betray your self confessed muslim religion, my dear

jazakAllah Dantes!


i warned you of this, my dear jazakAlr ylah.

that you chose to ignore is your cross to bear.

a house divided is seminary 1011

adiou me amigo.


"...that he would be torn apart by the jackals of unleavened..."

someone may have said that sometime, once.

bon apetite my good amigos, adeiu.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1091342


the monsters of the unleavenened , i have not misspoken thus.

may the flag of many pardons fly from your yardarms sir,

adieu an infinitum

my friend.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1091464
United States
09/06/2010 07:40 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Actually you should. All religions and spiritual systems come up short in one way or another[/b].


here you betray your self confessed muslim religion, my dear

jazakAllah Dantes!


i warned you of this, my dear jazakAlr ylah.

that you chose to ignore is your cross to bear.

a house divided is seminary 1011

adiou me amigo.


"...that he would be torn apart by the jackals of unleavened..."

someone may have said that sometime, once.

bon apetite my good amigos, adeiu.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1091342


the monsters of the unleavenened , i have not misspoken thus.

may the flag of many pardons fly from your yardarms sir,

adieu an infinitum

my friend.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 07:41 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
to the two posters above me. ...Yes I was in formation I have an undegraduate degree from Texas A & M in philosophy I lived at hart hall on campus. I spent two years previous to that in formation. I was torn between a diocesan priest and being a religous trinitarian friar. Their main place for formation is in baltimore maryland. Father Albert Ansuweszki was the vocations director at the time. Their charism was the redemption of the captives. I stayed in their three story red rick monastery for some time. I also visited with the legionnaires of christ with father obannon and the redemptorists in san antonio texas as well as Snow mass abby (benedictine trappist monastery in colorado). Beyond these words there is no ''proof'' that I can satisfy you with.


Edmond,

Jumping all around the country...hmmm.

"Their main place for formation is in Baltimore Maryland."


Who is "Their" and anyone can type in a name. I checked, there is nothing to be found on a Father Albert Ansuwezki.

You've made it all up. No one can stand habitual liars.
Go to Confession is my advise, be truthful from then on...

Im a liar huh? ok here:

since you searched and found nothing ...
[link to www.trinitarianhistory.org]
 Quoting: Edmond Dantes


OP. I apologize. Still, to make things clear, give me the dates you spent there and the name of your superior, is Father Ansuwezki? I could check to see if he knew you.

Post if you don't mind, to prove you are being honest,
your last name, the initial of your first name and the
time period you spent at Holy Trinity.

A major question, how could a seminarian, when did you stop believing in the Holy Eucharist?



thanks,
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 08:14 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Reply to the Protestant English Inquisition and persecution and we see until this day of Catholics!!

Thomas More was martyred because he would not bow down to
the lies of Protestant heresy.

And there is a beautiful country enslaved right now because of Protestantism. Did you forget Ireland.


Pardon me Peewee, but have you ever noticed that "religion" in general and the abegod blood cults in particular are all about slavery?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 725839


I respect you enough not to call you a mocking name. Do the
same. Slavery is a lame constantly used reason not to believe. It's not true. No one makes you believe anything.

You take the easy way and try to justify it. So obvious.

You can change though, your eternal life depends on it.
Fallenmonk

User ID: 1091407
United Kingdom
09/06/2010 08:17 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
OP do you feel like you have a close relationship with the Father, like a friendship ?.

You may not be willing to answer this but I will ask anyway.

Is it right for Muslims to lie to save their asses(sura) when God commands us to not lie. A lie is a lie after all is it not ?

I am an ex catholic and leaving them was one of the best things I have done because I never would have found out what the truth is.

Keep well and God bless.
"Traveling through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops, boy! "
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 08:18 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Reply to the Protestant English Inquisition and persecution and we see until this day of Catholics!!

Thomas More was martyred because he would not bow down to
the lies of Protestant heresy.

And there is a beautiful country enslaved right now because of Protestantism. Did you forget Ireland.


Pardon me Peewee, but have you ever noticed that "religion" in general and the abegod blood cults in particular are all about slavery?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 725839


Ac 825839,

You didn't reply to the Protestant inquisition in England and their persecution of Catholics in Ireland and here.

Did you change the subject for a reason?
Fallenmonk

User ID: 1091407
United Kingdom
09/06/2010 08:22 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
to the two posters above me. ...Yes I was in formation I have an undegraduate degree from Texas A & M in philosophy I lived at hart hall on campus. I spent two years previous to that in formation. I was torn between a diocesan priest and being a religous trinitarian friar. Their main place for formation is in baltimore maryland. Father Albert Ansuweszki was the vocations director at the time. Their charism was the redemption of the captives. I stayed in their three story red rick monastery for some time. I also visited with the legionnaires of christ with father obannon and the redemptorists in san antonio texas as well as Snow mass abby (benedictine trappist monastery in colorado). Beyond these words there is no ''proof'' that I can satisfy you with.


Edmond,

Jumping all around the country...hmmm.

"Their main place for formation is in Baltimore Maryland."


Who is "Their" and anyone can type in a name. I checked, there is nothing to be found on a Father Albert Ansuwezki.

You've made it all up. No one can stand habitual liars.
Go to Confession is my advise, be truthful from then on...

Im a liar huh? ok here:

since you searched and found nothing ...
[link to www.trinitarianhistory.org]


OP. I apologize. Still, to make things clear, give me the dates you spent there and the name of your superior, is Father Ansuwezki? I could check to see if he knew you.

Post if you don't mind, to prove you are being honest,
your last name, the initial of your first name and the
time period you spent at Holy Trinity.

A major question, how could a seminarian, when did you stop believing in the Holy Eucharist?



thanks,
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929


Op no need to post your last name here. Beware of inflitrators.

Last Edited by Sword of mercy on 09/06/2010 08:25 PM
"Traveling through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops, boy! "
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 08:22 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
OP do you feel like you have a close relationship with the Father, like a friendship ?.

You may not be willing to answer this but I will ask anyway.

Is it right for Muslims to lie to save their asses(sura) when God commands us to not lie. A lie is a lie after all is it not ?

I am an ex catholic and leaving them was one of the best things I have done because I never would have found out what the truth is.

Keep well and God bless.
 Quoting: Fallenmonk


It's going to be difficult for you, when you see you chose
to leave the Truth. Protestantism is man-made. If you
could just believe in the Holy Eucharist Fallenmonk.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 08:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
to the two posters above me. ...Yes I was in formation I have an undegraduate degree from Texas A & M in philosophy I lived at hart hall on campus. I spent two years previous to that in formation. I was torn between a diocesan priest and being a religous trinitarian friar. Their main place for formation is in baltimore maryland. Father Albert Ansuweszki was the vocations director at the time. Their charism was the redemption of the captives. I stayed in their three story red rick monastery for some time. I also visited with the legionnaires of christ with father obannon and the redemptorists in san antonio texas as well as Snow mass abby (benedictine trappist monastery in colorado). Beyond these words there is no ''proof'' that I can satisfy you with.


Edmond,

Jumping all around the country...hmmm.

"Their main place for formation is in Baltimore Maryland."


Who is "Their" and anyone can type in a name. I checked, there is nothing to be found on a Father Albert Ansuwezki.

You've made it all up. No one can stand habitual liars.
Go to Confession is my advise, be truthful from then on...

Im a liar huh? ok here:

since you searched and found nothing ...
[link to www.trinitarianhistory.org]


OP. I apologize. Still, to make things clear, give me the dates you spent there and the name of your superior, is Father Ansuwezki? I could check to see if he knew you.

Post if you don't mind, to prove you are being honest,
your last name, the initial of your first name and the
time period you spent at Holy Trinity.

A major question, how could a seminarian, when did you stop believing in the Holy Eucharist?



thanks,


Op no need to post your last name here.
 Quoting: Fallenmonk



Figure out a way the OP can prove he was in the Seminary
Mr. Anti-Catholic. Always the former Catholics...will do
anything to knock the faith even to defend someone else
leaving it to become Muslim.
Fallenmonk

User ID: 1091407
United Kingdom
09/06/2010 08:29 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
OP do you feel like you have a close relationship with the Father, like a friendship ?.

You may not be willing to answer this but I will ask anyway.

Is it right for Muslims to lie to save their asses(sura) when God commands us to not lie. A lie is a lie after all is it not ?

I am an ex catholic and leaving them was one of the best things I have done because I never would have found out what the truth is.

Keep well and God bless.


It's going to be difficult for you, when you see you chose
to leave the Truth. Protestantism is man-made. If you
could just believe in the Holy Eucharist Fallenmonk.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929


I could no longer be part of the whore. But you go ahead kissing the pope middle finger or supporting a church whose bank vaults are run by the mafia. You going to tell me to say 50 hail Marys next ?.
"Traveling through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops, boy! "
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1090917
United States
09/06/2010 08:37 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Name a good fruit of Islam? You can't.

Read and learn about mevlana & ibn'l arabi
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1091013


And you're in Turkey. You should know hundreds of good Muslims. I know many who are students at my university.
Fallenmonk

User ID: 1091407
United Kingdom
09/06/2010 08:39 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
to the two posters above me. ...Yes I was in formation I have an undegraduate degree from Texas A & M in philosophy I lived at hart hall on campus. I spent two years previous to that in formation. I was torn between a diocesan priest and being a religous trinitarian friar. Their main place for formation is in baltimore maryland. Father Albert Ansuweszki was the vocations director at the time. Their charism was the redemption of the captives. I stayed in their three story red rick monastery for some time. I also visited with the legionnaires of christ with father obannon and the redemptorists in san yuppieantonio texas as well as Snow mass abby (benedictine trappist monastery in colorado). Beyond these words there is no ''proof'' that I can satisfy you with.


Edmond,

Jumping all around the country...hmmm.

"Their main place for formation is in Baltimore Maryland."


Who is "Their" and anyone can type in a name. I checked, there is nothing to be found on a Father Albert Ansuwezki.

You've made it all up. No one can stand habitual liars.
Go to Confession is my advise, be truthful from then on...

Im a liar huh? ok here:

since you searched and found nothing ...
[link to www.trinitarianhistory.org]


OP. I apologize. Still, to make things clear, give me the dates you spent there and the name of your superior, is Father Ansuwezki? I could check to see if he knew you.

Post if you don't mind, to prove you are being honest,
your last name, the initial of your first name and the
time period you spent at Holy Trinity.

A major question, how could a seminarian, when did you stop believing in the Holy Eucharist?



thanks,


Op no need to post your last name here.



Figure out a way the OP can prove he was in the Seminary
Mr. Anti-Catholic. Always the former Catholics...will do
anything to knock the faith even to defend someone else
leaving it to become Muslim.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929


Faith ? The catholic church is just one big man made tradition. If the pope had real faith he would tear down all the statues, give all the gold to the poor,he would drive out all the satanists,he would gather all his priests and march into every muslim country preaching the truth. But instead he prefers the safety of his thrown. Can you imagine the Apostles living like he does.
"Traveling through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops, boy! "
Fallenmonk

User ID: 1091407
United Kingdom
09/06/2010 08:41 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Bedtime.God bless you all
"Traveling through hyperspace ain't like dusting crops, boy! "
kalamity kool

User ID: 734307
United States
09/06/2010 08:53 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
I spent 6 years studying in college to become a Roman Catholic priest....History Archeaology Philosophy etc...I am a convert to Islam.

I make no apology. I am not here to apostlytize.

I am going to show how I came to this ...and allow others to see some of my thoughts in this regard as requested by others here on GLP.

++++I reserve the right to ignore people on this thread due to the personal nature of it.+++++

I am posting my thoughts for GLP to share and discuss not for me to Lead this thread.

first the basics....

Why believe in a god in the first place?
cosmological teleological ontological proofs notwithstanding....Mathematics in Rene descartes 7 days meditations takes geometry from ''origin'' (0,0,0) in an effort to deduce from God a world.....Geometry works today. aether Physics quantum mechanics too many others to list...

Well whats God like then if he exists?
Omnibenevolent Omniscient Omnipotent etc...these are Necessary Qualities to ascribe to a God by DEFINITION.....ie it is a tautology to define God as anything else.

Well then I started to discern the various religions based upon my understandings of the above....
example:
Norse have Thor and Odin amongst other Gods....the essence being a split of power = not Omnipotent....thus fail.

worship of the Sun
sun = urning plasma etc...=not Omniscient= fail

and proceeded with more and more mythos and religions until to my satisfaction had the three Abrahamic ones.

I Judaism
II Christianity
III Islam

First to christianity....
For 1500 years there was no differentiation (only after Martin Luther wrote his theses) in OFFICIAL church doctorine.

After the council of Nicea (and consequently the edict of milan that made christianity the official religion of rome) was there a consensus in belief....these occured around the year 300

During the deliberations the apocrypha were denoted and summarily exiled from the bible(yes parts of the bible were debated and removed).

this lead to differing interpretations of theology which persist to today. ....ie 2nd maccabbees...purgatory issue.''holy thought to pray for the dead''...etc.

in essence a disagreement over what should be in the bible and thus belief

Judaism follows the Torah
Which is itself written in various form EJP (elohist yawhist priestly) versions...during the abylonian captivity.
Essentially the jews copied Sumerian stories and attributed the stories to ''judaic'' essences..

example
Noahs flood account= Epic story of Gilgamesh which is much older and was in the area written on the ziggurat that the jews were captured in....
Moses=Sargon1st parallels possibly etc.
even the story of david slaying goliath goliath= Elhanan, the son of Jaareoregim slew goliath...David served the phillistines against the israelites.
the point is the stories have been manipulated to serve theological ends....

Which leads to Islam which says in Essence The bible is correct except for ''XYZ'' and ''xyz'' interpretations are wrong....it actually went down like this....

a long intro I know ...again I make no apology. I am merely sharing why I am muslim. Judging from the fact that thousands of peoeople have read my threads I guess there is at least one ''good muslim''....I wish GLP would end its tirade of hate against Islam. I wish you all well.God bless us all.
 Quoting: Edmond Dantes



Took me a while to understand just why you rejected Christianity,
it came down to this?

"in essence a disagreement over what should be in the bible and thus belief"

for me the disagreements are a sign of life..

"Which leads to Islam which says in Essence The bible is correct except for ''XYZ'' and ''xyz'' interpretations are wrong....it actually went down like this...."

isn't that just a further disagreement?

Christianity is the result of the last major historical interaction of God with the people of this planet.
I've never understood the preoccupation with which religion contained the most truth at the beginning, surely the God of your definition would keep moving things along?

Last Edited by kalamity kool on 09/06/2010 09:31 PM
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 725839
United States
09/06/2010 09:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Pardon me Peewee, but have you ever noticed that "religion" in general and the abegod blood cults in particular are all about slavery?


Ac 825839,

You didn't reply to the Protestant inquisition in England and their persecution of Catholics in Ireland and here.

Did you change the subject for a reason?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1073929


LMAO..did I stutter? I could care less which verion of blood cult you worship,or which blood cult did what to another blood cult... They are all truly wicked in nature and practice.

You, and all abegod blood cultists worship an insidious, capricious, bloodthirsty beast who jerks off to the smell of burning human and animal flesh.

To top it all off, you PROUDLY choose to worship catholicism,,THE most insidious of the sun god blood cults.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 09:19 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
OP do you feel like you have a close relationship with the Father, like a friendship ?.

You may not be willing to answer this but I will ask anyway.

Is it right for Muslims to lie to save their asses(sura) when God commands us to not lie. A lie is a lie after all is it not ?

I am an ex catholic and leaving them was one of the best things I have done because I never would have found out what the truth is.

Keep well and God bless.


It's going to be difficult for you, when you see you chose
to leave the Truth. Protestantism is man-made. If you
could just believe in the Holy Eucharist Fallenmonk.


I could no longer be part of the whore. But you go ahead kissing the pope middle finger or supporting a church whose bank vaults are run by the mafia. You going to tell me to say 50 hail Marys next ?.
 Quoting: Fallenmonk


Fallenmonk, the "Babylon" is world wide, it is the
sin of the world now not just one city. And your "whore" term comes from Ellen White, founder of the 7th Day Adventists! You quote a non-Christian woman who started
her own sect. You are going with her...to mock the faith
of your baptism?

These are weak excuses, when are you ever going to be in the
presence of the Holy Father to show Him any respect? Kissing the middle finger of the Pope. I am not sure if it
is a requirement or just a respectful tradition or a made up
Protestant protest.

Those are your reason for leaving the faith? It does probably have to do with prayer and Mass and the requirements. Do you realize...the Roman Catholic requirements are from God? Some of the required, recall, are the 10 Commandments. God asks so little, He gave you life, now and for eternity. Believe, what you think is so
difficult like the prayer of the Hail Mary are given to help you more than a must do. And the Hail Mary isn't
a requirement, it's an extra benefit.

You wish to decide for yourself, maybe it's another "chip"
on your shoulder or simply you don't know the faith. The
"grace" of the Sacraments were given to us by Our Lord to
help us get to Heaven FM.
Edmond Dantes  (OP)

User ID: 1032690
Canada
09/06/2010 09:28 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
I spent 6 years studying in college to become a Roman Catholic priest....History Archeaology Philosophy etc...I am a convert to Islam.

I make no apology. I am not here to apostlytize.

I am going to show how I came to this ...and allow others to see some of my thoughts in this regard as requested by others here on GLP.

++++I reserve the right to ignore people on this thread due to the personal nature of it.+++++

I am posting my thoughts for GLP to share and discuss not for me to Lead this thread.

first the basics....

Why believe in a god in the first place?
cosmological teleological ontological proofs notwithstanding....Mathematics in Rene descartes 7 days meditations takes geometry from ''origin'' (0,0,0) in an effort to deduce from God a world.....Geometry works today. aether Physics quantum mechanics too many others to list...

Well whats God like then if he exists?
Omnibenevolent Omniscient Omnipotent etc...these are Necessary Qualities to ascribe to a God by DEFINITION.....ie it is a tautology to define God as anything else.

Well then I started to discern the various religions based upon my understandings of the above....
example:
Norse have Thor and Odin amongst other Gods....the essence being a split of power = not Omnipotent....thus fail.

worship of the Sun
sun = urning plasma etc...=not Omniscient= fail

and proceeded with more and more mythos and religions until to my satisfaction had the three Abrahamic ones.

I Judaism
II Christianity
III Islam

First to christianity....
For 1500 years there was no differentiation (only after Martin Luther wrote his theses) in OFFICIAL church doctorine.

After the council of Nicea (and consequently the edict of milan that made christianity the official religion of rome) was there a consensus in belief....these occured around the year 300

During the deliberations the apocrypha were denoted and summarily exiled from the bible(yes parts of the bible were debated and removed).

this lead to differing interpretations of theology which persist to today. ....ie 2nd maccabbees...purgatory issue.''holy thought to pray for the dead''...etc.

in essence a disagreement over what should be in the bible and thus belief

Judaism follows the Torah
Which is itself written in various form EJP (elohist yawhist priestly) versions...during the abylonian captivity.
Essentially the jews copied Sumerian stories and attributed the stories to ''judaic'' essences..

example
Noahs flood account= Epic story of Gilgamesh which is much older and was in the area written on the ziggurat that the jews were captured in....
Moses=Sargon1st parallels possibly etc.
even the story of david slaying goliath goliath= Elhanan, the son of Jaareoregim slew goliath...David served the phillistines against the israelites.
the point is the stories have been manipulated to serve theological ends....

Which leads to Islam which says in Essence The bible is correct except for ''XYZ'' and ''xyz'' interpretations are wrong....it actually went down like this....

a long intro I know ...again I make no apology. I am merely sharing why I am muslim. Judging from the fact that thousands of peoeople have read my threads I guess there is at least one ''good muslim''....I wish GLP would end its tirade of hate against Islam. I wish you all well.God bless us all.



Took me a while to understand just why you rejected Christianity,
it came down to this?
"in essence a disagreement over what should be in the bible and thus belief"
for me the disgreements are a sign of life..

"Which leads to Islam which says in Essence The bible is correct except for ''XYZ'' and ''xyz'' interpretations are wrong....it actually went down like this...."

isn't that just a further disagreement?
 Quoting: kalamity kool

First, Thankyou for at least trying to understand. Further disagreement that can be verified. The Quran is unadulterated. There is only one ''version''.Inside the Quran are references to things that humanity has only recently begun to understand scientifically. The disagreements ended for me when a message was given with clarity.

Fallenmonk
Yes I am close to God.

To the poster who wanted me to Post my name...No. I have been attacked verbally long enough. I do not need to be attacked physically.

To all I am tired and will be going to bed now. Good night and God bless you all.
1:1.618 ratio
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1073929
United States
09/06/2010 09:29 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Roman Catholic Seminarian turned Muslim...My experiences.
Pardon me Peewee, but have you ever noticed that "religion" in general and the abegod blood cults in particular are all about slavery?


Ac 825839,

You didn't reply to the Protestant inquisition in England and their persecution of Catholics in Ireland and here.

Did you change the subject for a reason?


LMAO..did I stutter? I could care less which verion of blood cult you worship,or which blood cult did what to another blood cult... They are all truly wicked in nature and practice.

You, and all abegod blood cultists worship an insidious, capricious, bloodthirsty beast who XXXXXXXXXXXXX

To top it all off, you PROUDLY choose to worship catholicism,,THE most insidious of the sun god blood cults.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 725839


What a gentleman, I want to follow what you believe, love your idiot pornographic reply.

You've repeated the same "blood cult" whatever it meant three times. Think for yourself. Ah, the "sun god" put down, another of E.G. White's terms.

Don't speak of Catholic sin till you can defend your own
inquisition and persecution of others. Can you imagine
Ireland to ever be one peaceful Catholic Nation that it
once was Ac>

I am so sorry, it's obvious you don't understand or know
anything about the faith.

Which Protestant sect were you baptized into?





GLP