We've been thru your BS theory already, lol. NY is far from herd immunity, only a fifth of the population have been infected per the scientists. Thus the reason they are doing so well now is they have an incredible amount of tests, track and trace, mask wearing, not going full retard with opening bars, restaurants, basically mitigating the virus the best they can, which allows them to stop it dead in its tracks.

The fact is that other countries that had a good amount of testing, and track and trace of contacts such as Germany and South Korea, they never suffered a severe outbreak.