Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 940 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 303,895
Pageviews Today: 461,392Threads Today: 179Posts Today: 2,338
05:20 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued

 
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 04:51 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Getting dark out there but this is a live view of the toxic mess:

[link to www.youtube.com (secure)]
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Larphillips

User ID: 83270745
United States
02/06/2023 05:04 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Yeah, the ‘boom’ happened. Massive fire column and insane black plume.
“A person is smart, people are stupid.”
“Nobody knows until everybody knows”
Larphillips

User ID: 83270745
United States
02/06/2023 05:05 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Look at the sky above the smoke column…that’s all from this burning release.
“A person is smart, people are stupid.”
“Nobody knows until everybody knows”
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:07 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Look at the sky above the smoke column…that’s all from this burning release.
 Quoting: Larphillips


Yeah it has been pretty windy for the last couple days around here, but today it is just as calm as can be...thank God, but you can see that in how it has just created that giant black cloud over EP.
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Devoted Follower
User ID: 84985188
United States
02/06/2023 05:07 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It looks volcanic.

The plume is so large that it's underside has flattened out in the upper atmosphere.

hiding
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:10 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Getting dark out there but this is a live view of the toxic mess:

[link to www.youtube.com (secure)]
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Thanks for the video link.

That black cloud is sooty incomplete combustion. Looks a lot like a crude oil fire to me, but could be other things.

Those people are danger close and talking with no respirators on. I hope they are lucky.
Justme
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:15 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Getting dark out there but this is a live view of the toxic mess:

[link to www.youtube.com (secure)]
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Thanks for the video link.

That black cloud is sooty incomplete combustion. Looks a lot like a crude oil fire to me, but could be other things.

Those people are danger close and talking with no respirators on. I hope they are lucky.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Yeah I'm trying to figure out how to use this website...

[link to www.windfinder.com (secure)]


and determine if this cloud will be passing over my house in Beaver Co. Pa
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Flying Elvii

User ID: 84802739
United States
02/06/2023 05:17 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Yeah, the ‘boom’ happened. Massive fire column and insane black plume.
 Quoting: Larphillips


Phosgene gas....
Everyone there is going to see affects that won't start for 24 hours or so.
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:19 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Getting dark out there but this is a live view of the toxic mess:

[link to www.youtube.com (secure)]
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Thanks for the video link.

That black cloud is sooty incomplete combustion. Looks a lot like a crude oil fire to me, but could be other things.

Those people are danger close and talking with no respirators on. I hope they are lucky.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Yeah I'm trying to figure out how to use this website...

h


and determine if this cloud will be passing over my house in Beaver Co. Pa
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Ventusky is the best wind app out there.

I also have an app called My Radar where you can get wind speeds and directions at different elevations.

I grew up in Beaver (up on the hill Brighton Township off Dutch Ridge), so I feel for you guys.


Looks like you have a 4 to 5 mph wind speed coming from the NW, flowing toward SE

[link to www.ventusky.com (secure)]

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 05:23 PM
Justme
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:23 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
...


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Thanks for the video link.

That black cloud is sooty incomplete combustion. Looks a lot like a crude oil fire to me, but could be other things.

Those people are danger close and talking with no respirators on. I hope they are lucky.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Yeah I'm trying to figure out how to use this website...

[link to www.windfinder.com (secure)]

Looks like you have a 4 to 5 mph wind speed coming from the NW, flowing toward SE


and determine if this cloud will be passing over my house in Beaver Co. Pa
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Ventusky is the best wind app out there.

I also have an app called My Radar where you can get wind speeds and directions at different elevations.

I grew up in Beaver (up on the hill Brighton Township off Dutch Ridge), so I feel for you guys.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Ventusky works thank you.
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Flying Elvii

User ID: 84802739
United States
02/06/2023 05:23 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It looks volcanic.

The plume is so large that it's underside has flattened out in the upper atmosphere.

hiding
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


Did none of these morons even bother to look at the winds ABOVE GROUND LEVEL?

That plume is not going where they expected it to.



Last Edited by Flying Elvii on 02/06/2023 05:23 PM
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:23 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
...


That giant plume of black smoke looks toxic as fuck!
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Thanks for the video link.

That black cloud is sooty incomplete combustion. Looks a lot like a crude oil fire to me, but could be other things.

Those people are danger close and talking with no respirators on. I hope they are lucky.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Yeah I'm trying to figure out how to use this website...

h


and determine if this cloud will be passing over my house in Beaver Co. Pa
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


Ventusky is the best wind app out there.

I also have an app called My Radar where you can get wind speeds and directions at different elevations.

I grew up in Beaver (up on the hill Brighton Township off Dutch Ridge), so I feel for you guys.


Looks like you have a 4 to 5 mph wind speed coming from the NW, flowing toward SE

[link to www.ventusky.com (secure)]
 Quoting: JustmeTX


bmp
Justme
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:24 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It looks volcanic.

The plume is so large that it's underside has flattened out in the upper atmosphere.

hiding
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


Did none of these morons even bother to look at the winds ABOVE GROUND LEVEL?

That plume is not going where they expected it to.


 Quoting: Flying Elvii


I just did. 5 mph flowing toward Beaver. NW winds. pretty uniform up to a few thousand feet anyway.

at 10,000 feet, wind is about 29 mph, coming from NNW

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 05:26 PM
Justme
Devoted Follower
User ID: 84985188
United States
02/06/2023 05:28 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It looks volcanic.

The plume is so large that it's underside has flattened out in the upper atmosphere.

hiding
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


Did none of these morons even bother to look at the winds ABOVE GROUND LEVEL?

That plume is not going where they expected it to.


 Quoting: Flying Elvii


It doesn't look like much if any real planning went into this.

Looks like they're just winging it.

burnit
Larphillips

User ID: 83270745
United States
02/06/2023 05:31 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today

Last Edited by Larphillips on 02/06/2023 05:31 PM
“A person is smart, people are stupid.”
“Nobody knows until everybody knows”
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:33 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It looks volcanic.

The plume is so large that it's underside has flattened out in the upper atmosphere.

hiding
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


Did none of these morons even bother to look at the winds ABOVE GROUND LEVEL?

That plume is not going where they expected it to.


 Quoting: Flying Elvii


It doesn't look like much if any real planning went into this.

Looks like they're just winging it.

burnit
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


You're probably right about winging it. There was a quick little news briefing last night with the Mayor of EP and the rairoad dude and the top cop and watching that little get together, and watching them all race for the door and take no questions when it was over was in no way a comforting feeling for people like me who are apparently now down wind from this thing!
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Larphillips

User ID: 83270745
United States
02/06/2023 05:34 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
It doesn't look like much if any real planning went into this.

Looks like they're just winging it.

burnit
 Quoting: Devoted Follower 84985188


As soon as they said that the railroad was in charge of this ‘controlled release’ I knew what to expect.

EVERYTHING they do is being run through all their lawyers to mitigate lawsuits. Not what is best for the people, the land, or the environment. It will all be about what class action lawyers can prove. They’ve effectively muddied the waters here (literally and figuratively.)
“A person is smart, people are stupid.”
“Nobody knows until everybody knows”
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:36 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today
 Quoting: Larphillips


Holy shit that don't look very controlled. They're probably just straight up lying about having any control.
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:40 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today
 Quoting: Larphillips


Wow. I guess all that black stuff is what comes off a vinyl chloride fire. It will have a LOT of HCl Acid produced.
And some amount of Phosgene. (Edit: Upon further reading, I don't think Phosgene is produced in any appreciable quantities).
[link to www.govinfo.gov (secure)]


The HCl will close your airway immediately if you get a whiff of it. (speaking from experience). It will also burn the eyes badly. (the HCL gas dissolves into tears).

[link to pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (secure)]

[link to pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (secure)]

"Phosgene appears as a colorless gas or very low-boiling, volatile liquid with an odor of new-mown hay or green corn. Extremely toxic. Warning properties of the gas inhaled are slight, death may occur within 36 hours (Lewis, 3rd ed., 1993, p. 1027). Prolonged exposure of the containers to intense heat may result in their violent rupturing and rocketing. Rate of onset: Immediate & Delayed (Lungs) Persistence: Minutes - hours Odor threshold: 0.5 ppm Source/use/other hazard: Dye, pesticide, and other industries; history as war gas, corrosive/irritating."

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 06:51 PM
Justme
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 05:45 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today
 Quoting: Larphillips


Wow. I guess all that black stuff is what comes off a vinyl chloride fire. It will have a LOT of HCl Acid produced.

That will close your airway immediately if you get a whiff of it. (speaking from experience). It will also burn the eyes badly. (the HCL gas dissolves into tears).
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Am I right in assuming...if you know...that there are a lot of variables on where much of this comes down and in what concetrations? I guess we can't even tell how high the plume will go or how far it will carry.

1dunno1
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 05:51 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today
 Quoting: Larphillips


Wow. I guess all that black stuff is what comes off a vinyl chloride fire. It will have a LOT of HCl Acid produced.

That will close your airway immediately if you get a whiff of it. (speaking from experience). It will also burn the eyes badly. (the HCL gas dissolves into tears).
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Am I right in assuming...if you know...that there are a lot of variables on where much of this comes down and in what concetrations? I guess we can't even tell how high the plume will go or how far it will carry.

1dunno1
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


A lot will depend on what the wind is doing, minute by minute.

Also upon humidity and if it starts to rain.

The wind up at 30,000 feet is around 100 knots headed SSE if I remember. So once it gets up there, (IF it gets up there) it is pretty much gone. But the soot is likely heavier and once it cools will likely limit its rise to the that level.
Maybe around 10,000 feet is where it looks like it is collecting.

any rain will bring the HCl down as acid rain and pit the paint on anyone's vehicles left outside.

I had a modelling program at one place I worked where I modelled chemical hazardous release scenarios, so I have some experience. It looks to me like they opened up too large of a hole in that tank. Wind is a good thing. It will dilute the effects quite a bit.

I would not expect a temperature inversion, but that would be a very bad thing obviously.

It would have been nice if they could have fashioned some sort of burner to get more complete combustion. That huge soot cloud is just nasty. Will likely come dripping down on whoever is downwind once it cools off and condenses the contents of the cloud.



No sure about the phosgene or how much is produced. If it comes down in any significant concentration, it is deadly. It is a war weapon, or used to be. I just don't have experience with it.

Edit: (I don't think any appreciable amount of Phosgene is produced. Just HCl. WHich is bad enough. )

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 06:52 PM
Justme
Larphillips

User ID: 83270745
United States
02/06/2023 05:57 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Look at that cloud… (not my photo)

https://imgur.com/jTKVtbo

“A person is smart, people are stupid.”
“Nobody knows until everybody knows”
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 84016376
United States
02/06/2023 05:59 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to twitter.com (secure)]
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 84630424
United States
02/06/2023 06:02 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued


...the coughing in the video
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 06:04 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
By the way, phosgene is quite heavy (MW=91 vs air at 28.8), and colorless. So it will likely drop to ground level rather quickly, however much is produced.

[link to pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (secure)]

Seems like they could be more definitive in the literature about how much is produced when vinyl chloride burns.

Hopefully it is a minor byproduct of incomplete combustion.

Edit: (I don't think any appreciable amount of Phosgene is produced. Just HCl. WHich is bad enough. )

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 06:52 PM
Justme
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 84016376
United States
02/06/2023 06:05 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Tomato plants in.

bump
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 06:07 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 84630424


Like I just posted. The phosgene produced will depart from the soot cloud and hug the ground once it cools. It is 3 times more dense than air.

That shit can be fatal and you can't see it. See the literature. Slight odor of new mown hay.

A dust mask is useless. You need an activated carbon respirator at a minimum. (with the inlet and exhalation valves).

That guy coughing is risking his life being there. They need to get out of there, unless they have the right equipment.

[link to pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov (secure)]

Edit: (I don't think any appreciable amount of Phosgene is produced. Just HCl. WHich is bad enough. )

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 06:53 PM
Justme
The Don Of Nantucket

User ID: 80692948
United States
02/06/2023 06:12 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
[link to www.wfmj.com (secure)]

Drone shot of the explosion today
 Quoting: Larphillips


Wow. I guess all that black stuff is what comes off a vinyl chloride fire. It will have a LOT of HCl Acid produced.

That will close your airway immediately if you get a whiff of it. (speaking from experience). It will also burn the eyes badly. (the HCL gas dissolves into tears).
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Am I right in assuming...if you know...that there are a lot of variables on where much of this comes down and in what concetrations? I guess we can't even tell how high the plume will go or how far it will carry.

1dunno1
 Quoting: The Don Of Nantucket


A lot will depend on what the wind is doing, minute by minute.

Also upon humidity and if it starts to rain.

The wind up at 30,000 feet is around 100 knots headed SSE if I remember. So once it gets up there, (IF it gets up there) it is pretty much gone. But the soot is likely heavier and once it cools will likely limit its rise to the that level.
Maybe around 10,000 feet is where it looks like it is collecting.

any rain will bring the HCl down as acid rain and pit the paint on anyone's vehicles left outside.

I had a modelling program at one place I worked where I modelled chemical hazardous release scenarios, so I have some experience. It looks to me like they opened up too large of a hole in that tank. Wind is a good thing. It will dilute the effects quite a bit.

I would not expect a temperature inversion, but that would be a very bad thing obviously.

It would have been nice if they could have fashioned some sort of burner to get more complete combustion. That huge soot cloud is just nasty. Will likely come dripping down on whoever is downwind once it cools off and condenses the contents of the cloud.



No sure about the phosgene or how much is produced. If it comes down in any significant concentration, it is deadly. It is a war weapon, or used to be. I just don't have experience with it, except is messed up my great uncle pretty bad. But he was 100 years old by the time I was old enough to meet him, and he was deaf by then, so no real way to communicate.
 Quoting: JustmeTX


Thanks for all that. Guess I better get to the store real quick before the damn cloud gets any bigger and grab a few things.
PLATA BITCHEZZZZZZ

UPGRADE UNAVAILABLE

The Rolling Stones said it best...

"What's confusing you is the nature of my game"
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 85218098
02/06/2023 06:13 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Burning polyvinyl CHLORIDE produces phosgene.
Burning polyvinyl does not, but still terrible stuff.
JustmeTX

User ID: 84369183
United States
02/06/2023 06:16 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Breaking – Massive Train Derailment in East Palestine Ohio, Shelter in Place Issued
Burning polyvinyl CHLORIDE produces phosgene.
Burning polyvinyl does not, but still terrible stuff.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 85218098


They said this is vinyl chloride (monomer) I believe. (not poly)

Looks like terribly incomplete combustion.

Last Edited by JustmeTX on 02/06/2023 06:17 PM
Justme





GLP